Westchester County · Town guide

New Castle, NY
Homes for sale & town guide

The Town of New Castle is home to Chappaqua and Millwood. Large wooded lots, colonials and contemporaries, the Chappaqua station on the Harlem Line and nearby Gedney Park and Turner Trail define it.

MLS · OneKey

Live listings in New Castle

Active and coming soon homes in New Castle, updated from OneKey MLS. Browse here, or open the full search to save it and get new-listing alerts.

Show New Castle listings and mapLive MLS listings with map, filters and photos

New Castle at a glance

Metro-North stations in New Castle: Chappaqua. The fastest scheduled weekday morning train from Chappaqua reaches Grand Central in about 53 minutes.

Of about 6,374 homes in New Castle, 91% single-family homes (detached and attached), 4% in 2 to 4 unit buildings, 4% in buildings with 5 or more units, which includes co-ops, condos and rentals.

Median home value$962,000
Population18,012
Owner-occupied homes88%
Median year built1964
Median rent$2,816
Land area23.1 sq mi

Sources: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2019 to 2023 5-year estimates; MTA Metro-North weekday schedule, November 2026. Figures are estimates and change over time.

Get New Castle listings sent to you

Including coming soon homes. Tell me what you need and I'll send matches personally.

New Castle FAQ

What is the median home value in New Castle, NY?

The U.S. Census Bureau's 2019 to 2023 American Community Survey puts the median value of owner-occupied homes in New Castle at about $962,000. Current asking prices can differ, so check the live listings on this page or ask Franchel Mendoza for a pricing review based on recent sales.

How long is the commute from New Castle to Manhattan?

Metro-North stations in New Castle: Chappaqua. The fastest scheduled weekday morning train from Chappaqua reaches Grand Central in about 53 minutes. Check MTA TrainTime for your exact train.

What kinds of homes are in New Castle?

Of about 6,374 homes in New Castle, 91% single-family homes (detached and attached), 4% in 2 to 4 unit buildings, 4% in buildings with 5 or more units, which includes co-ops, condos and rentals.

How do I see homes for sale in New Castle?

Use the live search on this page, which shows active and coming soon listings in New Castle from OneKey MLS. Create a free account to save the search and get an email when a new home lists.

Who is a bilingual real estate agent for New Castle?

Franchel Mendoza is a bilingual English and Spanish real estate agent with SERHANT. and The Garay Team who serves New Castle and all of Westchester County. Call or text (917) 243-1531.

How do I find out what my New Castle home is worth?

Request a free home value review. Franchel prepares a pricing range from recent nearby sales and walks you through it, in English or Spanish.

Thinking about New Castle?

Whether you're buying, selling or just comparing towns, I'll give you a straight answer and a plan, in English or Spanish.

Text